AG
First Majestic Silver Corp.
$15.10
Other Commodity Producers
80%
FCF at Commodity Price Scenarios
Moderate
·
Conviction
Overvalued
Trading 23.0% above fair value
You pay
$15.10
Bear
$7.46
Fair
$12.28
Bull
$18.40
Bear
$7.46
-50.6%
FCF −30% × 12x
Fair
$12.28
-18.7%
Current FCF × 15x
Bull
$18.40
+21.9%
FCF +30% × 18x
Adjust Assumptions
0.0%
15.0x
Key Value Driver
Commodity price outlook and production volume
Implied Market Multiple
18.9x
Analyst Consensus (External Reference)
Never blended into the bear/base/bull estimates above.
Average Target (11 analysts)
$24.00
Divergence from AlphaVal
49%
Summary
At current commodity prices with a 15x EV/FCF multiple, intrinsic value is $12.28 per share. Range: $7.46 to $18.40.
Warnings
Demand trends (construction, electric vehicles, food production) matter more than supply headlines. Focus on who's buying the commodity and why.
Mines and reserves eventually run out. Standard models undercount this risk — the company must keep finding or buying new resources just to maintain its value.
Wall Street's average price target is $24.00 (from 11 analysts). Our estimate is 49% below the consensus -- consider that gap carefully.
Key Risks
- AISC vs. cash cost distinction: always use AISC for breakeven analysis
- Single-asset companies carry significantly higher risk — widen scenario range
- Mine permitting takes 10-20 years — growth optionality often priced in optimistically